Let’s look at the remaining free agents. Who might be of use to the Phillies?

January is drawing to a close, which means there will be a mad scramble for remaining free agents that have been left to twist in the wind. At some point, their demands for that extra year, those few million dollars, will fall by the wayside, tossed aside in the hopes of finding employment for the 2026 season. We can have a separate conversation about how the CBA has increasingly killed the middle class of free agents, but the way the market sets itself up these days, those players that are in that 1.5-3 WAR area are usually squeezed out of the game of finding long term deals. What we’ll start to see is more players start agreeing to deals that are one year if they’re lucky, a minor league deal with a spring invitation if they’re willing and able. The Phillies were already able to do that Friday night when they signed Dylan Moore to a minor league deal.

That makes it an appropriate time to see which players that are still on the market that might be attractive to the Phillies. This isn’t a comprehensive list, rather a smaller one of players that might fit a very specific need the team might have from the outside looking in.

Miguel Andujar

Michael Baumann over at Fangraphs wrote a great piece looking for players that might hold a platoon advantage that can be of use for teams looking to fill out their roster. One quote that kind of stuck out to me was this:

A short-side platoon bat — even an incredible one, like Refsnyder — is a bit of a luxury player. That goes double when the player in question is stuck on the lower end of the defensive spectrum. It’s not always easy to carry a guy like that, let alone invest in a good player for that role.

If the Phillies were looking at someone like Andujar, it would be specifically for that role, the one of platoon player with Brandon Marsh or Justin Crawford (or both). Andujar would be one that slides into the position of being a lefty killer from the right side, creating some kind of Frankenstein player with either of the two lefties that could raise the floor of the outfield as a whole. That might cut down on his playing time quite a bit, something he may not be interested in if he’s still harboring ideas of being a starter on a team, but it would give the team a serious weapon against southpaws.

Defensively, Andujar is a butcher. His -5 OAA in left field would be a significant downgrade for a team that looks to be making sure their outfield defense is at least average in the corners, if not something more. Putting Andujar there with either Marsh or Crawford in center would be inviting potentially disastrous results, which might also be the reason he remains a free agent.

Tommy Pham

Now, listen first before making your fantasy football jokes.

One of the bigger factors here is going to be age. Pham is 37 years old right now, but will play the 2026 season as a 38 year old as his birthday is in March. No team is going to be handing him a starting job, so it’s probably safe to say he’ll be open to a platoon position. In order to do that job, though, he needs to be good at it. He needs to be someone who is still hitting left handed pitching well.

Well, how does an 82 wRC+ against left handed pitching in 2025 sound?

That is going to be the issue with Pham. If he’s not able to produce against left handed pitching better than what he did in 2025, he’s going to be a liability with the team. Career against lefties, he’s got a 121 wRC+, so there is hope that he can repeat his past successes. His under the hood metrics suggest that perhaps last year was a bit of blip, so extending a minor league deal his way could give the team some depth.

Justin Verlander/Max Scherzer/Chris Bassitt

If you had to convince me that the team could use another starting pitcher, the argument from me would be minimal. As good as I think Andrew Painter is going to be, simply handing him a starting spot in the rotation might be a bit foolhardy. At the very least, he should have to win a competition to win a job, something he is projected to do considering the current candidates to do battle with him.

But what if the team brought in a veteran like this trio to actually pose a threat to his and Taijuan Walker’s spot?

Consider: neither of these three veteran pitchers would likely sign with the Phillies had they not been guaranteed a spot in the rotation. Even as they are in the twilight of their respective careers, there is enough pride in each one that they would not want to risk being cut and having to ride buses in the minor leagues, not to mention some milestones that are at least theoretically in reach that they would want to continue marching towards. They likely would not even want a minor league deal, something the Phillies would probably only be willing to offer to continue maintaining some flexibility in their roster.

However, these are at least some enticing names to look into to see if there is a fit.