Alejandro Kirk is a 27-year-old, right-handed hitting catcher from Tijuana, Mexico. He’s played the last five seasons (plus 9 games) with the Jays. In 564 MLB games, he has a .268/.345/.398 batting line with 51 home runs, 1 stolen base and a 11.3 bWAR (fWAR likes him better, 14.9 career). When he came up, we […]
Alejandro Kirk is a 27-year-old, right-handed hitting catcher from Tijuana, Mexico. He’s played the last five seasons (plus 9 games) with the Jays.
In 564 MLB games, he has a .268/.345/.398 batting line with 51 home runs, 1 stolen base and a 11.3 bWAR (fWAR likes him better, 14.9 career).
When he came up, we thought he would be a good bat/ok glove catcher, but his defense has been terrific. Baseball Savant has him at the 100th percentile for ‘Fielding Run Value’, as well as 100th percentile for Blocks Above Average (as much as we continue to be told that the one-knee-down catching cause more wild pitches/passed balls) and 98th percentile for Framing.
Kirk wasn’t all that great at throwing out baserunners this year, 56th percentile. He was great early, through the end of June he had thrown out 15 of 49 stealers (31%). The rest of the way he was 2 of 37 (5%). I don’t know what happened; maybe there was an injury that we didn’t know about.
On the season he threw out 22% of base streals, in 2024 he threw out 31%.
And, of course, he’s slow. Baseball Savant has him at the 1st percentile in Baserunning Run Value, and Sprint Speed is 2nd percentile. I tend to think the talk about his speed is overblown, If I have to choose between a fast catcher and a great defensive catcher, I’ll take the latter.
I think the same thing when people complain that he’s heavy. I’d rather have a very good catcher than a catcher in great shape. As John Kruk said ‘He’s a baseball player, not an athlete’. Again, I’d rather the ballplayer than the athlete. Of course, he’s my middle son’s favourite players, my son says he can relate to Krik, he can’t relate to
Kirk is in the 91st percentile in hard hit balls, squared-up balls and expected batting average. He’s 95th percentile in strikeout percentage.
His best season with the bat was 2022, when he hit .285/372/.415. I think he’s going to have a season where he puts it all together with the bat and his .300+ with 20+ home runs.
Steamer thinks he’ll play 106 games this year, with a .276/.354/.435 line and 14 home runs for a 4.2 fWAR.
Category: General Sports
