Report: Mauricio Pochettino could be set for huge Tottenham Hotspur return

Tottenham Hotspur weigh options as pressure grows on Thomas Frank

Tottenham Hotspur find themselves at a familiar crossroads, balancing patience with performance as scrutiny intensifies around Thomas Frank’s early months in North London. According to reporting by Caught Offside, internal conversations have begun regarding Frank’s long term future, even though the club hierarchy are not yet preparing for decisive action.

Frank arrived in the summer of 2025 with a reputation for tactical clarity and player development, yet results have failed to match expectation. As Caught Offside state, “The future of Thomas Frank as Tottenham Hotspur manager is becoming uncertain, with mounting pressure on the Danish coach following a string of poor performances and growing discontent among supporters.” That sense of unease has been fuelled by displays that have lacked cohesion and conviction.

Boardroom patience tested by form

Tottenham’s ownership group ENIC continue to show restraint. The report notes that “Spurs’ owners, ENIC, are not currently planning an immediate dismissal.” There remains a belief that Frank “deserves more time to implement his tactical ideas and stabilise the team.”

However, patience is being tested by evidence on the pitch. Defeats and dropped points have carried weight beyond the league table. The 3-0 loss to Nottingham Forest is referenced as a flashpoint, while draws against lower ranked sides have deepened supporter frustration. One senior source sentiment captured in the piece suggests concern that the campaign could unravel if momentum is not recovered quickly.

Photo IMAGO

From an analytical standpoint, the issue appears less about isolated results and more about direction. The article highlights “lack of attacking rhythm, defensive vulnerability, and unclear identity” which are problems that resonate strongly with fans who expected immediate clarity from a coach renowned for structure.

Pochettino return dominates discussion

If change becomes unavoidable, the name leading internal discussions is familiar. Caught Offside report that “Mauricio Pochettino [has been] identified as the strongest potential replacement.” His emotional connection to the club is underlined, with the reminder that “The Argentine, who famously guided Spurs to the Champions League final in 2019, still holds enormous affection among supporters.”

There is also the practical complication that “Pochettino is currently the head coach of the United States men’s national team.” Yet his understanding of Tottenham’s infrastructure and his history of developing young players are viewed as compelling reasons to consider a return, should circumstances align.

Generated by IJG JPEG Library

Alternative candidates on shortlist

While Pochettino is framed as the frontrunner, contingency planning is evident. Caught Offside confirm that “Tottenham have also shortlisted Oliver Glasner and Marco Silva.” Glasner’s FA Cup success at Crystal Palace and Silva’s disciplined work at Fulham are cited as examples of Premier League proven adaptability.

These names suggest Spurs are prioritising managers who can impose structure quickly, a telling detail given the current concerns around identity and control.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

From a Tottenham supporter’s perspective, this report cuts deep but also carries a strange sense of hope. Nobody wanted Thomas Frank to struggle, especially after the optimism that followed his appointment. Many fans accepted that early turbulence was inevitable. What hurts more is the feeling that Spurs still look uncertain about who they are meant to be.

There is sympathy for Frank, particularly given injuries and transition, yet patience in football is always conditional. Supporters want to see a clear idea, even if results lag behind. Right now, that clarity feels elusive. The pressure he faces is immense, not just from results but from the weight of history and expectation that clings to this club.

The mention of Mauricio Pochettino inevitably stirs emotion. For many fans, his era represents belief, progress, and identity. A return would not be about nostalgia alone, it would be about reconnecting with principles that once made Spurs competitive and coherent. At the same time, supporters understand the risks of looking backwards.

What fans truly crave is alignment, between board, coach, and squad. Whether Frank can still deliver that remains uncertain, but this report makes one thing clear, the coming weeks could define not just his future, but the direction of Tottenham Hotspur itself.